Related Posts
Podcasts
What’s more important to you—getting a flood of leads quickly, or getting fewer leads that are more likely to buy?
It’s a question every business running paid ads needs to answer. And it often leads to the age-old debate: Lead Ads vs Website Conversion Ads.
One promises cheap, fast leads without users ever leaving Facebook or Instagram. The other sends people to your website, but at a higher cost—and potentially a higher quality.
The problem is, no one seems to give a straight answer about which one is better. Instead, you’re left wading through opinions, platform recommendations, and conflicting advice.
In this article, you’ll get a clear comparison of both ad types—what they do, their pros and cons, and when each one works best. By the end, you’ll have the information you need to choose the right strategy for your business and your budget.
What Are Lead Ads?
Lead Ads are a type of paid advertisement available on platforms like Facebook and Instagram.
Their main feature is simple but powerful—they allow users to submit their contact details directly within the platform without ever leaving the app.
When someone clicks on a Lead Ad, a pre-filled form pops up with information like their name and email address already populated. All they have to do is tap “Submit.”
The Pros of Lead Ads:
- Fewer steps, less friction: Users don’t have to leave Facebook or Instagram, so it’s quick and easy for them to hand over their details.
- Lower cost per lead: Because the process is so seamless, you often get leads at a cheaper price.
- Pre-filled information: The form pulls details from the user’s profile, making it faster and more convenient.
The Cons of Lead Ads:
- Lower lead quality: The ease of submitting a form often means people sign up without much thought. You may end up with more leads, but many will be unqualified or uninterested.
- Limited customisation: You can’t customise the form experience as much as you can on your own website.
- Harder to nurture: Since users don’t visit your site, you miss out on the chance to introduce them to your brand, content, and offers.
What Are Website Conversion Ads?
Website Conversion Ads are designed to drive people away from the social media platform and onto your website, where they can complete a specific action—such as filling out a contact form, signing up for a free trial, or making a purchase.
These ads use a platform’s pixel tracking (like the Facebook Pixel) to optimise for people who are most likely to convert once they land on your site.
Read: Why your paid ad traffic isn’t converting on your website
The Pros of Website Conversion Ads:
- Higher lead quality: People who click through and take action on your site are typically more intentional and engaged.
- Full control over the experience: You can customise your landing page, messaging, and data collection process without platform limitations.
- Better long-term nurturing: Visitors who land on your website can be retargeted, added to your email list, and exposed to your wider content and offers.
The Cons of Website Conversion Ads:
- Higher cost per lead: The additional step of leaving the platform often means fewer conversions and a higher cost per lead.
- Drop-off risk: Some users may click but abandon the process before filling in their details.
- Requires a solid website: If your landing page is slow, confusing, or poorly designed, your conversion rates will suffer.
Lead Quality vs Volume: The Real Difference
At first glance, it might seem like the choice between Lead Ads and Website Conversion Ads is just about cost. But the real difference runs deeper—it’s about lead quality versus lead volume.
Lead Ads typically generate a higher quantity of leads at a lower cost. But that doesn’t mean those leads are ready to buy. Because the process is so easy—just a couple of taps—many people submit their details without genuine interest. You’ll often end up with leads who don’t remember signing up, aren’t ready to buy, or aren’t the right fit at all.
Website Conversion Ads, on the other hand, usually deliver fewer leads at a higher cost. But those leads are often more engaged. They’ve taken extra steps: clicked the ad, waited for your site to load, and completed a form. That extra effort filters out people who aren’t serious, leaving you with leads who are more likely to convert down the line.
Quick Comparison:
| Metric | Lead Ads | Website Conversion Ads |
| Cost per Lead | Lower | Higher |
| Lead Volume | Higher | Lower |
| Lead Quality | Typically lower | Typically higher |
| User Effort | Minimal (form inside platform) | Higher (clicks through to website) |
| Customisation | Limited | Full control over landing page experience |
| Nurturing Potential | Lower | Higher (user visits your website) |
The key is understanding what matters more to your business: a high volume of leads, even if many don’t convert—or fewer, higher-quality leads that are more likely to become customers.
Which Is Better? It Depends on Your Goal
If you’re looking for a one-size-fits-all answer, here’s the reality—there isn’t one.
The “better” option depends entirely on your goals, your budget, and how your sales process works.
When Lead Ads Might Be Better:
- You want to build a big email list fast for future nurturing.
- You’re promoting a low-commitment offer like a free guide, newsletter, or giveaway.
- You have a limited budget and need to collect leads at scale.
- You’re happy to spend time and resources qualifying leads later through email sequences or phone calls.
When Website Conversion Ads Might Be Better:
- You want to capture higher-intent leads who are closer to making a purchase.
- You have a strong, well-optimised landing page and know how to convert visitors.
- Your sales process relies on leads being pre-qualified and educated.
- You’re running campaigns where the lead value is high enough to justify a higher cost per lead.
Think of it like this: If you’re fishing with a wide net and want to catch as many fish as possible, even if some aren’t a great catch—Lead Ads will do the job. If you’re fishing with a spear and want fewer, but higher-quality fish—Website Conversion Ads will serve you better.
How to Choose the Right One
When it comes to Lead Ads vs Website Conversion Ads, there’s no universal “best” option. It all comes down to what you want to achieve and how you plan to handle the leads once they come in.
If your priority is building a large database quickly, with the understanding that many of those leads may need more nurturing and qualification, Lead Ads can help you do that efficiently.
If you’re more focused on quality over quantity and want leads who are actively engaging with your brand and closer to buying, Website Conversion Ads are likely to deliver better results—even if they cost more upfront.
The most successful businesses don’t just pick one and stick with it blindly. They test both, measure the quality of the leads, and build a strategy that balances cost, volume, and lead intent.
The bottom line:
Lead Ads are great for speed and volume. Website Conversion Ads are better for intent and long-term sales. Choose based on your goals—not the cheapest option.
Regardless of which option you choose, you will need to ensure that your leads are high quality. Here’s a step by step approach to improve your lead quality from paid ads.
