Related Posts
Podcasts
You’ve tried remarketing ads before.
Maybe you set up a campaign, chose “website visitors,” added a logo, slapped on a tagline, and waited.
And… nothing. Barely any clicks. Zero conversions. Money down the drain.
So you gave up and told yourself, “Remarketing doesn’t work for my business.”
But here’s the thing: remarketing does work. You just did it wrong — and you’re not alone.
Most businesses make the same mistakes: targeting everyone who’s ever landed on their website, recycling the same bland creative, and treating remarketing like a “set and forget” checkbox.
It’s no wonder it flopped.
We’ve worked with hundreds of businesses, especially in B2B and long buying cycle industries, and we’ve seen firsthand how powerful remarketing can be when you do it right. We’ve turned underperforming campaigns into high-ROI machines using these strategies.
In this article, you’ll learn exactly why your remarketing hasn’t worked, and more importantly, the four ad types that consistently do. These aren’t random ideas. They’re backed by data and designed to work even if your website traffic is low.
Why Most Remarketing Fails
What is paid media? (A beginners guide)
Most remarketing campaigns flop for one of three reasons:
1. Your targeting is way too broad.
If you’re targeting everyone who visited your site in the past 60 or 90 days, you’re not remarketing, you’re spraying and praying.
Think about it: some of those people bounced after 5 seconds. Some landed on your blog by accident. Others were just browsing and had no real interest. None of them are ready to buy.
What you want is to reach people who are actively in the consideration or decision stage. The ones who checked your pricing page, visited your service pages, or spent a few solid minutes exploring. Those are your warm leads. Everyone else is noise.
2. You’re using the wrong creative.
Most remarketing ads are just logos with a catchy tagline. That’s not going to cut it.
Your buyer is probably shopping around. They’ve filled out two or three other contact forms. They’ve opened new tabs. You need to hit them with value, proof, and relevance — not vague branding.
If your ad looks like it was designed to tick a box rather than convert a customer, you’ve already lost.
3. You’re treating it as “set and forget.”
This one’s a killer. You launch a remarketing campaign and then… leave it running for months. Same audience. Same ad. Same message.
That leads to ad fatigue. Your frequency climbs. People stop noticing your ad, or worse, get annoyed by it. Either way, conversions drop.
The best remarketing campaigns evolve. They rotate creative, test new angles, and follow the user’s journey with content that actually aligns to where they’re at.
The Key Mindset Shift
Here’s the truth most marketers miss: remarketing isn’t about reaching everyone, it’s about reaching the right people at the right time.
Think of your remarketing audience like a funnel. At the top, you’ve got people who barely know you. They clicked a blog post or visited your homepage once. Nice… but they’re not ready to convert.
At the bottom, you’ve got the gold: the people who viewed your pricing page, downloaded a resource, watched 75% of your video, or engaged with a product demo. These are the folks you need to double down on.
So instead of chasing volume, chase intent. Focus your remarketing ads on:
- People who visited key pages (like pricing or services)
- People who stayed on your site longer than 30–60 seconds
- People who engaged with your videos or clicked on previous ads
Even if your audience gets smaller, this might work better, because now you’re speaking directly to people who are much closer to buying.
This is where the real magic happens: pairing the right audience with the right creative.
The Four Remarketing Ads That Work
Best Paid Media Agencies in Australia: An Unbiased Review
If you’ve been relying on just one generic ad to win back potential buyers, it’s no surprise your remarketing isn’t working. The truth is, you need variety: different angles, different messages, all reinforcing the same core value.
Here are the four remarketing ad types that consistently drive conversions, across industries and audience sizes:
| Ad Type | What It Is | Why It Works | Pro Tips |
| Case Study Ad | A metric-focused ad highlighting a real client success | Builds trust through tangible results | Include logos, 1–2 strong metrics, and a clear CTA like “Grow with [Tool]” |
| Testimonial Ad | A quote from a happy customer (name, title, company) | Feels human and relatable | Use a short quote as the headline and a longer one in the body |
| Logo Ad | Visual grid of brands you’ve worked with | Social proof at a glance | Show as many credible logos as possible, not just one or two |
| Brand USP Ad | A bold statement of your unique selling point | Clarifies value instantly, reinforces positioning | Tie to a specific pain point or transformation, e.g., “X to Y” |
Examples of Remarketing Ad Types
Case Study Ads
Testimonial Ad
Logo Ad
Brand USP Ad
And another example of a USP Ad:
How to Make It Work With Low Traffic
One of the biggest objections we hear is: “This all sounds great, but I don’t have enough website visitors to run remarketing.”
If your traffic is low, you can focus on retargeting the following audiences:
- All website visitors in the last 30 days
- All Facebook and Instagram page engagers within the last 14 days
- All 50% video viewers in the last 30 days (this targets those that watch 50% or more of your videos on Facebook and Instagram)
And if you just started out, then you might want to consider first running a traffic campaign to get users to your site. You could consider using the USP style ads for traffic targeting a broader audience, and then retarget that traffic after a month with the other ad types.
And most importantly, you need to shuffle and introduce new ad creatives weekly.
Don’t Write Off Remarketing
If you’ve written off remarketing in the past, now you know why it didn’t work and more importantly, how to fix it.
It’s not about blasting everyone who’s visited your website. It’s about finding the right people — the ones closest to buying — and showing them the right message at the right time.
Here’s your simple action plan:
- Stop targeting everyone.
Refine your audiences to focus on high-intent visitors and engaged users. - Rotate your creative.
Use the four ad types: Case Study, Testimonial, Logo Grid, and Brand USP. Keep your content fresh and aligned to your buyer’s journey. - Build momentum.
If your audience is small, start with top-of-funnel content and use engagement to build up a remarketing list. - Test, learn, and adapt.
Watch your frequency, update your ads regularly, and experiment. This isn’t a “set and forget” strategy — it’s one of the highest ROI plays when done right.
Remarketing isn’t dead. It just needs a smarter approach. And now, you’ve got the blueprint.
If you’re looking for an audit of your existing Paid Media Campaigns, get in touch with one of our experts here.
