Common Email Nurturing Mistakes (And How to Do it Properly)  | RedPandas Digital
Common email nurturing mistakes (And How to Do it Properly) 

Common Email Nurturing Mistakes (And How to Do it Properly) 

Let’s see if this sounds familiar: You’ve put a lot of effort into building a nurturing campaign for your email list. You’ve crafted emails you believe are perfect. But when you look at the data, open rates are disappointing, click-through rates are barely there, and your leads aren’t turning into customers. Frustrating, right?

Let’s see if this sounds familiar: You’ve put a lot of effort into building a nurturing campaign for your email list. You’ve crafted emails you believe are perfect. But when you look at the data, open rates are disappointing, click-through rates are barely there, and your leads aren’t turning into customers. Frustrating, right? 

Here’s the thing: It’s not your fault.  

Many marketers fall into common traps that sabotage their nurturing efforts, and recognising these issues is the first step to fixing them. 

We’ve seen all the mistakes businesses make and the impact they have. But the good news is that with the right adjustments, you can transform your campaigns into a trust-building, conversion-driving engine. 

In this article, you’ll learn about the biggest email nurturing mistakes that could be holding you back and, more importantly, how to correct them.  

And then, we can make this happen: 

Identifying Common Email Nurturing Mistakes 

When it comes to nurturing leads, most marketers have good intentions but sometimes miss the mark.  

The mistakes aren’t always obvious, but they can quietly sabotage your campaigns.  

meme about receiving an email from a company

Here are the common pitfalls to watch out for: 

  • Setting the Wrong Goal: If your only objective is to push leads through the sales funnel, you’re missing a crucial step. The goal shouldn’t be just about moving people closer to the finish line—it’s about building trust first. You can do this by educating your buyer and adding value 
  • Being Too “We-Focused”: Nobody likes hanging out with someone who only talks about themselves, and your leads feel the same way about your emails. If your content is constantly bragging about your company’s greatness, you’re turning people off. They’re more interested in how you can solve their problems than hearing your own success stories 
  • Following Rigid Formulas: Using a one-size-fits-all approach doesn’t cut it anymore. The “delay two days, send top-of-funnel, then middle-of-funnel” strategy makes assumptions that don’t hold true for every lead. You end up putting people through the same pattern even though they have different needs and timelines 
  • Assuming All Leads Will Convert Quickly: Expecting leads to progress smoothly down the funnel assumes that everyone is ready to buy on your schedule. This makes your campaign feel like a hard sell, which turns people off if they aren’t ready. Focus on education, not on sales 
  • Ignoring Personalisation: Sending generic emails might be easier, but it doesn’t resonate. If your campaign isn’t tailored to your lead’s unique challenges, they’ll feel like just another number and tune out 
  • Relying on Formulaic Content: While frameworks can help streamline your work, sticking too rigidly to a script makes your emails feel robotic. If you’re always pitching the same products in the same way, your audience will quickly become disengaged 
  • Lack of Engagement Metrics: If you’re not regularly reviewing metrics like click-through rates or segmenting based on interest, you’re flying blind. Failing to measure engagement prevents you from iterating and improving your campaigns 

These mistakes create a disconnect between you and your audience, eroding trust and making your emails feel like noise instead of valuable content.  

Let’s break down why these mistakes can harm your campaigns and how you can avoid them. 

Why These Mistakes Harm Your Campaigns 

meme about tips in sending email

Understanding where nurturing goes wrong is crucial, but knowing why these mistakes are harmful is just as important.  

Here’s a breakdown of how these errors can damage your email marketing efforts and what you can do about it:  

Email Nurturing Mistake Effect on Marketing What you can do about it  Example 
Setting the Wrong Goal Focusing solely on sales funnels ignores the reality that nurturing should build relationships and trust. If leads feel like they’re being forced through a predetermined path, they may abandon your emails entirely. Focus on building relationships and trust with your leads. Offer valuable content instead Send a welcome email series that offers useful resources and answers your buyers most pressing questions, without pushing for a sale. 
Being Too “We-Focused” Over-emphasising your own achievements comes across as self-centered, which alienates potential customers. People engage with brands that understand their challenges, so if your emails lack empathy, your audience will tune out. Show empathy and understanding of your buyer’s challenges. Show them that you understand where they’re at, how they feel, and what they need to change it Share a customer success story that demonstrates how your product solved a common problem your leads face 
Following Rigid Formulas Treating every lead the same way makes assumptions about their needs and buying journey that simply don’t hold up. Leads are left feeling like they’re being boxed into a one-size-fits-all pipeline that doesn’t cater to their specific needs or timelines. Segment your email list based on different criteria (e.g., behaviour, interests) and tailor your content to each segment’s needs. Create different lead magnets for different product ranges, and start to segment your list based on the products or topics they show interest in. Then, set up email nurturing for each with relevant content. 
Assuming All Leads Will Convert Quickly Not all prospects are ready to buy right away. Pushing too hard for a quick conversion may leave a sour taste in their mouth and drive them to a competitor who respects their decision-making process. Respect your leads’ decision-making process and provide value at each stage of their journey as opposed to selling your product or service. You can use the 5 stages of customer awareness model to do that Offer a Buyer’s Guide instead of pushing for an immediate purchase, allowing leads to explore your product at their own pace. 
Ignoring Personalisation Generic emails make your prospects feel undervalued. Without personalisation, your emails won’t stand out, and leads will be less likely to open future messages or engage with your content. Use personalisation techniques such as including the recipient’s name and tailoring content to their interests. Send personalised birthday emails with a special discount or offer tailored to the recipient’s previous purchases. Or simply add personalisation tokens to your email, like ‘first name.’ 
Relying on Formulaic Content Predictable or repetitive emails lack the creativity and variety that keep people interested. Formulaic content makes your campaigns feel like a chore rather than a benefit to your leads. Introduce variety and creativity in your email content. Use different formats and topics to keep your audience engaged. Alternate between newsletters, product updates, customer stories, and educational content to maintain interest. 
Lack of Engagement Metrics If you’re not tracking how people respond to your emails, you’re guessing what’s working. Without data on engagement, you can’t optimise your campaigns, which leaves you wasting time on ineffective strategies. Track and analyse email engagement metrics (open rates, click-through rates, etc.) to optimise your campaigns. Split test different email elements to get an understanding of what your audience responds best to.  Use an email marketing platform to monitor engagement metrics and adjust your strategies based on the data.  

Now that you know how to avoid these pitfalls and what to do instead, let’s look at some email nurturing best practices.  

Best Practices for Proper Email Nurturing 

Getting email nurturing right isn’t about following rigid formulas or being overly sales-focused. Instead, the best campaigns focus on building genuine trust with your audience. Here’s how to do it. 

First, put your email recipients in the driver’s seat.  

meme about a man sitting in driver's seat
Shouldn’t you be empowering your Buyer’s, just like this? 

Let them choose the kind of content they’re most interested in by incorporating interest-based self-selection fields into your forms. This way, when someone fills out a form that isn’t directly related to a sale, you can segment them into more relevant content, increasing the chances they’ll engage. Make sure your forms aren’t cumbersome—nobody wants to spend too much time filling them out.  

The experience should be quick and easy

Next, personalise your campaigns to your audience’s specific challenges and interests. A “choose your own adventure” approach helps engage leads because they can see themselves in your messaging. For instance, after someone fills out a form, ask them a follow-up question about their main marketing challenge. Depending on their answer, send them down a tailored content path that addresses their specific needs and offers helpful information. This shows you understand their challenges and are there to help. 

Trust is built gradually. Your emails should give recipients valuable, trust-building information rather than hard sales pitches. Instead of nudging them directly to speak with a sales rep, nurture them with insightful content that genuinely helps them overcome their challenges. This way, when they’re ready to talk to a sales representative, they’ll remember your brand as the one that offered helpful advice from the beginning. 

Don’t forget to measure engagement. Check the metrics on what resonates with your audience, such as click-through rates, and continue to refine your approach. Testing different subject lines, email formats, and call-to-action styles will help you understand what keeps your audience coming back for more. 

The final piece of the puzzle is maintaining a consistent brand personality across your campaigns. This ensures your emails feel like a continuation of the same conversation rather than a series of disjointed pitches. 

By focusing on personalisation, allowing leads to choose their own path, and building trust with valuable content, your nurturing emails will stand out and help you build meaningful connections with your audience. 

So, What’s Next? 

It’s easy to fall into the trap of making common email nurturing mistakes. But when you focus on building trust and offering your audience value at every touchpoint, you set the stage for nurturing campaigns that engage your leads and keep them coming back. 

And that’s all it’s about. Building trust.  

So, how can you build trust with your audience through all your content?  

Read: Why Trust is the Ultimate Ingredient in Sales & How to Build It  

Why Trust is The Ultimate Ingredient for Sales

Subscribe to our Awesome Newsletter
Get the best content marketing insights right in your inbox!